A warmly lit neighborhood shop window in a brick storefront, with light early-season snow along a quiet Aspen sidewalk.

Carl's Pharmacy Is Changing Hands. Can Downtown Aspen Keep Its Everyday Stores?

November 12, 2026

Carl's Pharmacy, at 306 E. Main St., sells prescriptions alongside toys, groceries, alcohol, clothing and jewelry. Across Main Street, the Miners' Building houses the hardware store that Carl and Katie Bergman opened in 1976, 11 years after they bought the small drugstore. Both stores have stayed in the family ever since. Both are now under contract to new owners.

The new owners say they intend to keep both stores running. Downtown Aspen has spent years trying to protect stores like these with ordinances, subsidies and, most recently, a nonprofit land trust. The trust is the town's most ambitious tool so far, and it doesn't expect to preserve its first property until 2027. Until then, the pharmacy and hardware counters on Main Street depend on a letter the buyers wrote to the stores' employees.

The Promise Covers Two Uses

The Aspen Daily News reported on Oct. 30 that the buyers plan to "preserve the pharmacy and hardware uses, listen to the teams and community and thoughtfully invest in the businesses over time." The paper obtained their Oct. 12 letter to store employees, which says they intend to keep the existing teams and "continue operating Carl's and Miners' as they have been."

The same letter is candid about what comes later. "It would be dishonest to say we don't have ideas for how the businesses could evolve, but we've intentionally made no plans at this time," it reads, and the buyers say they will "listen and learn" from staff before planning any changes.

The commitment is precise. It names the pharmacy and hardware uses. The rest of what makes Carl's feel like a mid-century general store, from the toy aisle to the jewelry case, falls under "operating as they have been." That is a clear statement of intent for now, made by owners who say they see the purchase as "a long-term investment in both businesses and in Aspen."

Linda Brining, daughter of the founders, told the Daily News the family was "very excited to find purchasers with a desire and ability to keep Carl's Pharmacy and Miners' Building Hardware serving the community for years to come." The deal hasn't closed yet. It is waiting mainly on a pharmacy license from the Drug Enforcement Administration, which the Daily News reported on Oct. 29 must be issued before the sale can be completed.

Because of that condition, this sale includes a licensed pharmacy as well as two buildings, and federal approval comes before the keys change hands.

Why Everyday Stores Leave Downtown

Rent is why the Carl's promise carries so much weight. In an April 2026 Daily News feature, the city put Aspen's average retail rent at $275 to $325 per square foot. The paper noted that luxury chains can pay that rate, while local owners have a much harder time. Recent closures show the pressure in practice:

  • Mi Chola closed in September 2025 after nearly 10 years at Main and Mill streets. Its owner told Aspen Public Radio that the last month's rent was $42,000 and a renewed lease would have raised it to $85,000 a month.
  • Aspen Eclectic, the toy, game and gift shop at 635 E. Cooper Ave., announced Friday, Sept. 4, 2026, as its last day after 16 years at that address. Owners Carrie and Larkin Horn were nearing the end of their lease, according to the Daily News. "This is big, for the toy store of a tourist town to close its doors," Carrie Horn told the paper.
  • The 2017 formula-retail ordinance, which requires a conditional-use review for chain stores in new development, has never brought a chain proposal before the Planning and Zoning Commission in nearly a decade. Existing buildings and projects already in the permit pipeline were exempt. Community Development Director Ben Anderson told the Daily News it "just hasn't been super effective."

Residents have noticed. The city's 2026 community survey found that about 75% of respondents expect to stay in Aspen for the next five years, down from 84% in 2024, the Daily News reported on Oct. 2. Sonya Wyntick, the city's survey consultant with Polco, summed up one theme in the results: "Residents would like to see more access to businesses and services that meet their regular needs."

Carl's and Miners' are those businesses, in nearly literal terms: a pharmacy and a hardware store, both on Main Street, both family-run for decades.

The Public Fix Runs on a 2027 Clock

The city's answer to closures like Mi Chola's is the Aspen Area Community Trust, a nonprofit land trust that the City Council formally acknowledged on March 24, 2026. It plans to acquire commercial property, sign affordable leases with use restrictions, and possibly add deed restrictions, with a focus on locally serving businesses that sell necessary goods and services. Board President Ann Mullins described the goal to the City Council, as quoted in the Daily News feature:

"This is not a competition with people in town. This is bringing back the laundromat, this is bringing back one more pharmacy, could we bring back a gas station?"

The trust would have to bring back "one more pharmacy" from scratch. Carl's, which already exists, is being kept open by a private sale. The trust's progress so far, drawn from Daily News reports on its startup funding and nonprofit status, the city's September 2026 grant resolution and Aspen Public Radio:

Milestone Date Detail
State planning grant 2023 $135,000 from the Colorado Department of Local Affairs to explore a community land trust
Startup funding March 2026 City agreed to the trust's $35,000 request to set up the nonprofit
Council acknowledgment March 24, 2026 Incorporation formally acknowledged
Nonprofit status Summer 2026 501(c)(3) secured; Aspen Community Foundation named fiscal agent for two years
Operating grant Sept. 15, 2026 One-time $25,000 from the city's General Fund
First preserved property Target: 2027 Planned, not yet acquired

Board member Chris Bendon told the council in August that the $25,000 would pay for a media coordinator to promote the trust and help recruit an executive director. Aspen Public Radio reported in late August that the trust hoped to preserve its first commercial property sometime in 2027.

Set against downtown rents, the city's two cash grants to the trust add up to $60,000, less than a month and a half of Mi Chola's $42,000 rent. The trust plans to rely on donors as well. Mayor Rachel Richards told the Daily News that one reason for running it outside government is speed, since a nonprofit with willing donors and a willing seller can move faster than city bureaucracy. Through this winter and into next year, though, decisions about the stores on Main Street are being made in private contracts.

The city already runs smaller versions of the same idea. Aspen Public House pays below-market rent in a city-owned space in the Wheeler Opera House building in exchange for affordable menu options, and the city selected 520 Grill for its subsidized restaurant space at 455 Rio Grande Place. Those deals work because the city owns the buildings. Carl's and Miners' are privately owned, so the city has no lease to set.

This Winter on Main Street

For anyone picking up a prescription or a box of screws, the stores are operating as usual while the license application moves forward. The buyers have described their immediate focus as "a smooth transition and continuity of service."

The city has also changed one rule with early-opening businesses in mind. Downtown's overnight parking ban now runs from 3 a.m. to 6 a.m., Nov. 1 through April 1. That is an hour shorter than last winter's 3 a.m. to 7 a.m. window, a change the city of Aspen says "helps support local businesses and community members who open early or recreate early." Warnings run through Nov. 15. After that, violations bring a $100 ticket, and cars left overnight during a snow event can be towed, with fees up to $260. Construction on Armory Hall has also switched Hopkins Avenue between Hunter and Galena streets, and Galena Street between Main Street and Hopkins Avenue, from angle to parallel parking.

Three dates will show how this plays out. The DEA license decides when Carl's officially changes hands. The trust's executive director hire decides whether it is staffed for its 2027 goal. The first property the trust preserves will show whether "one more pharmacy" can join the one Aspen still has at 306 E. Main St.

The long-term mix of downtown storefronts will be decided building by building, by owners choosing what to do with what they hold. If you own commercial property in Aspen and are considering its next chapter, Ashley Feddersen offers discreet, informed guidance on commercial and investment decisions in the core, backed by Team Tarumianz and Aspen Snowmass Sotheby's International Realty. Schedule a confidential consultation.

Have Questions?